The readability of CEO and Board Chair statements of JSE-listed mining companies in South Africa: The role of Women Directors and the narrative tone
Main Article Content
Abstract
Demographic attributes (e.g., gender differences) and reporting style (e.g., narrative tone) have consequences on the CEO and board chair’s statements in conveying the message to stakeholders. Other strands of the literature suggest significant differences in the effectiveness of statements written by women compared to those written by their male counterparts. These statements can be used to convey to stakeholders the entities' financial health and performance, growth prospects, sustainability efforts, and environmental factors. This paper examines the influence of the presence of women directors on the board and tone on the readability of CEO and Board Chair statements. The study analysed 136 firm-year reports from 17 JSE-listed mining companies covering the period 2014-2021, from which 272 board chair and CEO statements were extracted for textual analysis using Partial Least Squares structural equation modelling (PLS-SEM). The WD and the tone were found to be significantly and positively influencing the readability of the statements with respective coefficients of (β = .420, t-statistic = 5.316) and (β = .398, t-statistic = 6.926). The results imply that the presence of women on the boards improves transparency in reporting quality. Further, the tone in the statements can have consequences in that long and poorly written statements are less engaging, thus affecting their readability. The results align with the previous literature that argues in favour of gender-diverse boards and their association with tone and readability.
Article Details
Section
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
How to Cite
References
Ahmed, S., Jannat, R. & Ahmed, S.U. 2017. Corporate governance practices in the banking sector of Bangladesh: do they really matter? Banks and Bank Systems, 12(1), 27-35.
Albitar, K., Abdoush, T. & Hussainey, K. (2023). Do corporate governance mechanisms and ESG disclosure drive CSR narrative tones?. International Journal of Finance & Economics, 28(4): 3876-3890.
Al Lawati, H., Hussainey, K. & Sagitova, R. (2023). Forward-looking disclosure tone in the chairman’s statement: Obfuscation or truthful explanations. International Journal of Accounting & Information Management, 31(5): 838-863.
Al-Shaer, H. & Zaman, M. (2016). Board gender diversity and sustainability reporting quality. Journal of Contemporary Accounting & Economics, 12(3): 210-222.
Barkemeyer, R., Comyns, B., Figge, F. & Napolitano, G. (2014). CEO statements in sustainability reports: Substantive information or background noise? Accounting Forum, 38(4):241–257.
Bassyouny, H., Abdelfattah, T. & Tao, L. (2020). Beyond narrative disclosure tone: The upper echelons theory perspective. International Review of Financial Analysis, 70:1-13.
Ben-Amar, W., García-Meca, E., Francoeur, C. & Martínez-Ferrero, J. (2024). Do gender-diverse boards enhance the linguistic features of corporate financial reporting? Accounting Horizons, 38(2): 57-81.
Beretta, V., Demartini, M.C. & Sotti, F. (2023). Board composition and textual attributes of non-financial disclosure in the banking sector: Evidence from the Italian setting after Directive 2014/95/EU. Journal of Cleaner Production, 385: 1-15.
Bhuyan, A. K., Baid, C., Baid, D. & Mishra, M. (2023). Tone, Readability, and Firm Performance: A Study of Chairman’s Letter Across India and China. In Paradigm Shift in Business: Critical Appraisal of Agile Management Practices (pp. 51-75). Cham: Springer Nature Switzerland.
Buchholz, F., Jaeschke, R., Lopatta, K. & Maas, K. (2018). The use of optimistic tone by narcissistic CEOs. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, 31(2): 531-562.
Caldarelli, A., Allini, A., Salvatore, C., Zampella, A. & Meucci, F. (2022). Do corporate governance mechanisms affect the non-financial reporting readability? Evidence from Italy. Non-financial Disclosure and Integrated Reporting: Theoretical Framework and Empirical Evidence Springer, 3-28.
Carneiro, T., Da Nóbrega, R. V. M., Nepomuceno, T., Bian, G. B., De Albuquerque, V. H. C. & Reboucas Filho, P. P. (2018). Performance analysis of Google Colaboratory as a tool for accelerating deep learning applications. IEEE Access, 6: 61677-61685.
Dalwai, T., Mohammadi, S.S., Chugh, G. & Salehi, M. (2023). Does intellectual capital and corporate governance have an impact on annual report readability? Evidence from an emerging market. International Journal of Emerging Markets, 18(9): 2402-2437.
DeBoskey, D.G., Luo, Y. & Zhou, L. (2019). CEO power, board oversight, and earnings announcement tone. Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting, 52:657–680.
Department of Mineral Resources and Energy (DMRE). 2010. BBBEE Mining Charter. Available from: https://www.gov.za/sites/default/files/gcis_document/201409/33573838.pdf. (Accessed:30 June 2024).
Dowling, J. & Pfeffer, J. (1975). Organizational legitimacy: Social values and organizational behavior. Pacific Sociological Review, 18(1): 122-136.
Duad, N.M., Khidzir, N.Z., Ismail, A.R. & Abdullah, F.A.P. (2018). Validity and reliability of instrument to measure the effects of aviation English training. IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering, 340, 012063.
Enslin, Z., Du Toit, E. & Puane, M.F. (2023). The readability and narrative tone of risk and risk management disclosures for South African listed companies. Journal of Accounting in Emerging Economies, 15(1): 1-18.
Fahad, P. & Rahman, P.M. (2020). Impact of corporate governance on CSR disclosure. International Journal of Disclosure and Governance, 17(2), 155-167.
Fakir, A.A. (2020). Board of Directors’ Characteristics and Corporate Sustainability Performance: A Mediating Role of Internal Control Mechanisms (Doctoral Thesis, University of Malaya (Malaysia)).
Fisher, R., Van Staden, C.J. & Richards, G. (2020). Watch that tone: An investigation of the use and stylistic consequences of tone in corporate accountability disclosures. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, 33(1): 77-105.
Freeman, R. E. (1984). Strategic Management: A Stakeholder Approach. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
García-Sánchez, I.M., Suárez-Fernández, O. and Martínez-Ferrero, J. (2019). Female directors and impression management in sustainability reporting. International Business Review, 28(2): 359-374.
Giacomini, D., Martini, M., Sancino, A., Zola, P. & Cavenago, D. (2021). Corporate social responsibility actions and organizational legitimacy at the peak of COVID-19: a sentiment analysis. Corporate Governance: The International Journal of Business in Society, 21(6):1043–1058.
Ginesti, G., Drago, C., Macchioni, R. & Sannino, G. (2018). Female board participation and annual report readability in firms with boardroom connections. Gender in Management: An International Journal, 33(4): 296-314.
González, M., Guzmán, A., Pablo, E. & Trujillo, M.A. (2020). Does gender really matter in the boardroom? Evidence from closely held family firms. Review of Managerial Science, 14: 221-267
Guluma, T.F. (2021). The impact of corporate governance measures on firm performance: the influences of managerial overconfidence. Future Business Journal, 7(1): 1-18.
Hair, J. F., Risher, J. J., Sarstedt, M. & Ringle, C. M. (2019). When to use and how to report the results of PLS-SEM. European Business Review, 31(1): 2-24.
Hamad, S., Lai, F., Shad, M.K., Konečná, Z., Goni, F.A., Chofreh, A.G. & Klemeš, J.J. (2022). Corporate governance code and voluntary disclosure of integrated reporting: Evidence from an emerging economy. Sustainable Development, 30(6): 1497-1510.
Hambrick, D.C. & Mason, P.A. (1984). Upper echelons: The organization as a reflection of its top managers. Academy of Management Review, 9(2): 193-206.
Hamza, S. & Jarboui, A. (2024). ESG performance and disclosure quality: does a well-balanced board of directors matter when impression management occurs? EuroMed Journal of Business, 20(3): 698-720.
Hassan, M.K., Abu-Abbas, B. & Kamel, H. (2022). Tone, readability and financial risk: the case of GCC banks. Journal of Accounting in Emerging Economies, 12(4):716–740.
Hill, C.W. & Jones, T.M. (1992). Stakeholder‐agency theory. Journal of Management Studies, 29(2):131-154.
Hussain, N., Rigoni, U. & Orij, R.P. (2018). Corporate governance and sustainability performance: Analysis of triple bottom line performance. Journal of Business Ethics, 149(2):411-432.
Hossain, M.Z., Hasan, L. & Hasan, M.H. (2024). Corporate governance as a global phenomenon: evolution, theoretical foundations, and practical implications. Journal of Financial Risk Management, 13(2):342–375.
Hoque, Z. (2018). Methodological issues in accounting research. Spiramus Press Ltd.
Huang, X., Teoh, S. & Zhang, Y. (2014), “Tone management”, The Accounting Review, 89 (3):1083-1113.
Loughran, T. & McDonald, B. (2011). When is a liability not a liability? Textual analysis, dictionaries, and 10‐Ks. The Journal of Finance, 66(1):35-65.
Ludwig, P. & Sassen, R. (2022). Which internal corporate governance mechanisms drive corporate sustainability? Journal of Environmental Management, 301, 113780.
Mabindla, Z. (2018). Corporate governance: What more needs to be done? Accounting South Africa, 47–49. Available from: https://www.accountancysa.org.za/corporate-governance-what-more-needs-to-be-done/. (Accessed:08 June 2024).
Mankayi, S., Matenda, F. R., & Sibanda, M. (2023). An analysis of the readability of the chairman’s statement in South Africa. Risks, 11(3):1-15.
Martens, W. & Bui, C.N.M. (2023). An exploration of legitimacy theory in accounting literature. Open Access Library Journal, 10(1): 1-20.
Martikainen, M., Miihkinen, A. & Watson, L. (2022). Board characteristics and negative disclosure tone. Journal of Accounting Literature, 45(1): 100-129.
Maux, J. L., & Smaili, N. (2024). Do CEO gender and narcissism jointly affect CEO letter readability?. Journal of Corporate Accounting & Finance, 35(4):276–288.
Merkl-Davies, D.M. & Brennan, N.M. (2007). Discretionary disclosure strategies in corporate narratives: Incremental information or impression management? Journal of Accounting Literature, 26(2007): 116-196.
Metwally, A.B.M., El-Deeb, M.S. & Ahmed, E.A. 2024. Evaluating board characteristics’ influence on the readability of annual reports: insights from the Egyptian banking sector. Journal of Risk and Financial Management, 17(11):1-25.
Michelon, G., Trojanowski, G., & Sealy, R. (2022). Narrative reporting: State of the art and future challenges. Accounting in Europe, 19(1):7–47.
Michelon, G., Pilonato, S. & Ricceri, F. (2015). CSR reporting practices and the quality of disclosure: An empirical analysis. Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 33:59–78.
Mmako, N. (2016). The chairperson's statement: understanding prioritisation of discretionary disclosures by Johannesburg Stock Exchange-listed companies. Journal of Contemporary Management, 13(1): 385-408
Moraka, N.V. (2015). Transformation review in the South African mining industry: barriers affecting compliance to the Mining Charter. Problems and Perspectives in Management, 13(4):177-185.
Muslu, V., Mutlu, S., Radhakrishnan, S. & Tsang, A. 2019. Corporate social responsibility report narratives and analyst forecast accuracy. Journal of Business Ethics, 154(4): 1119-1142.
Nadeem, M. (2022). Board gender diversity and managerial obfuscation: Evidence from the readability of narrative disclosure in 10-K reports. Journal of Business Ethics, 179(1):153-177.
Nel, G.F., Arendse-Fourie, S.L. & Ontong, J.M. (2022). The association between optimism and future performance: Evidence of impression management from chief executive officer and chairperson letters. South African Journal of Business Management, 53(1):1-12.
Phesa, M. & Sibanda, M. (2023). Impression Management in Voluntary Narrative Disclosure through Length and Tone, Stakeholder Theory Lens. Journal of Accounting and Finance in Emerging Economies, 9(3): 383-394.
Post, C. & Byron, K. (2015). Women on boards and firm financial performance: A meta-analysis. Academy of Management Journal, 58(5):1546–1571.
Rahi, A.B.M. (2024). Unpacking women’s power on corporate boards: gender reward in board composition. International Journal of Disclosure and Governance, 22:64-8.
Ringle, C. M., Wende, S., and Becker, J.-M. 2024. "SmartPLS 4." Bönningstedt: SmartPLS, https://www.smartpls.com.
Sahar, E., Oradi, J. & Nazari, J.A. (2022). CEO gender and readability of annual reports: do female CEOs’ demographic attributes matter? Journal of Applied Accounting Research, 24(4): 682-700.
Sarstedt, M., Ringle, C. M., & Hair, J. F. (2017). Treating unobserved heterogeneity in PLS-SEM: A multi-method approach. Partial least squares path modeling: Basic concepts, methodological issues, and applications. Springer. 197-217.
Shin, T. & You, J. (2020). Changing words: How temporal consistency in a CEO's use of language toward shareholders and stakeholders affects CEO dismissal. Corporate Governance: An International Review, 28(1):47–68.
Theron, J.L. (2020). Identifying Financial Risk through Natural Language Processing of Company Annual Reports (Master's dissertation, University of Pretoria (South Africa)).
Tjano, R.N. (2021). An empirical study of corporate governance and sustainability reporting practices in South African state-owned entities. Doctoral Thesis. University of South Africa. Pretoria.
Varachia, Z. & Yasseen, Y. (2020). The use of graphs as an impression management tool in the annual integrated reports of South African listed entities. Journal of Economic and Financial Sciences, 13(1):1-11.